Originally Ed Mehlman & Associates Formerly Enduring Retail Audit Now Mehlman & Co.
— FAQ Mehlman & Co.

Common questions.
Plain answers.

A few of the things prospects ask us most. If you have a question that isn't covered here, send us a note.

Answers to questions
we often receive.

How does contingency pricing work? +

We operate purely on a contingency basis. Our fee is a percentage of the recoveries collected by you. If we find nothing, you pay nothing. Rates are calibrated to each engagement — factors include data volume, complexity, review window, and scope. Typical rates range approximately 25% to 40%+, but every rate is a conversation. We may not be the cheapest firm — we aim to return the highest net recovery to the client.

Recoveries flow directly to client P&L. Unlike consulting retainers, our work produces audit-traceable results within a single cycle.

How long does a typical engagement take? +

Our general timeline: 0–20 days for data receipt and conversion, 20–60 days for analysis and first claim submission, with subsequent cycles continuing as long as findings warrant. For many clients, engagements recur in six-month cycles year over year.

What data do you require? +

We work with the data you have, in whatever format you have it. Typical data requested includes AP historical payment files, purchase order data, vendor master files, transaction codes, receiving records, and access to invoices and vendor agreements. We only request additional data if necessary for the scope of work agreed.

How do you handle vendor relationships? +

Vendor correspondence is led by our US-based team — including a head of vendor relations who was previously a recovery auditor herself. We commit to 72-hour response on inquiries, work in the tone and style consistent with your corporate culture, and consider vendor relationships paramount to the success of every audit. Client approval is required before any claim is presented to a vendor.

Who actually does the work? +

Every auditor, analyst, and senior lead is based in the United States. No offshore team on the other end. No handoff to junior staff. Our typical engagement team is two to five senior people including at least one expert developer. Our resident CPA is available as a credentialed resource whenever an engagement benefits from one — and Tim leads every engagement as primary client contact.

Can you work alongside existing firms? +

Yes. We frequently conduct secondary audits — following a competitor firm — and regularly find material additional recoveries they missed. Clients successfully engage us after competitor audits. Our substantiation discipline keeps cancellation on processed claims under 9 %, so vendor relationships stay intact even when we reach deeper.

What industries do you serve? +

Our deepest expertise is in major retail — department stores, specialty chains, grocery — but we serve clients across manufacturing, logistics, hospitality, and beyond. Four decades of work with Fortune 1000 firms have shaped our detection library and our industry benchmarks.

Is there a minimum engagement size? +

No minimum, but we are selective about the engagements we accept. We bid only for work where we are confident we can deliver the best result. If an engagement doesn't fit our firm, we will tell you honestly — and typically refer you to a trusted alternative.

Still have questions?

Every engagement starts with a conversation. Tell us about your firm and we'll take it from there.

Begin a conversation